Cheap vs expensive umbrella: is a pricey one worth it
Cheap vs expensive umbrella: a good one costs more but survives wind and lasts years. Here is how to choose, with a simple cost per rain day table.
Hamza Idrissi3 min read
Verdict: buy one solid mid priced umbrella for daily use and one cheap spare for the car or office. A pricey designer one is rarely worth the jump.
The math in plain numbers
These are examples, not quotes.
| Umbrella | Price | Rain days it lasts | Cost per rain day |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheap | $8 | 10 | $0.80 |
| Mid | $30 | 150 | $0.20 |
| Designer | $100 | 200 | $0.50 |
The mid one wins because it holds up in wind. Wind flips cheap frames inside out and bends the ribs, and the umbrella goes in the bin.
Which wins on
| Factor | Cheap | Mid priced | Pricey |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wind | Often fails | Better, vented | Best, but not always |
| Weight | Light | Medium | Varies |
| Lifespan | Weeks to months | Years | Years |
| Fabric | Thin | Thicker, dries fast | Thick |
| Best for | Spare | Daily | Gift |
Pick the cheap one if
- You use it a few times a year.
- You want a spare in the car or at work.
- You tend to leave umbrellas on trains.
Pick the mid one if
- You commute in rain.
- You want it to stay steady in wind.
- You will use it at least once a week in the wet season.
Rule that matters most: look at the frame and the vent, not the logo. Fiberglass ribs bend and spring back. Thin metal ribs snap.
Features worth the money
- A vented top. Lets wind pass and stops flipping.
- Six or eight ribs. More ribs spread the load.
- A sturdy handle. Rubber or foam grips are comfortable when wet.
- Auto open and close. Handy with a bag in your hand, but one more part to break.
A caution on leaving it behind
The most expensive umbrella is the one you lose. If you forget things, stay in the cheap or mid range. A good thing to leave in a locker or on a hook at work.
If the extra money is a question for you in general, read what is worth spending more on and cost per use.
Quick questions
Is it worth paying more for an umbrella?
A mid priced one with a vented, fiberglass frame is worth it if you use it often. A designer price is not.
How do I stop my umbrella flipping in the wind?
Point the front into the wind and pick a vented model. Closing it in a gale beats fighting it.
Is a compact umbrella as strong as a full size one?
Usually less so. Full size frames are more stable.
How do I make an umbrella last?
Shake it dry and open it to dry fully before folding.
More to read
Keep reading
Bed sheets under $50: how to pick a set that lasts
How to buy bed sheets under $50 that feel good and last: what thread count really means, which fabrics suit you, and the signs of a bad set.
Hamza Idrissi5 min read
Everyday shoes under $50: what you get and what you do not
What a pair of everyday shoes under $50 can do well, how to check fit and the sole, and which signs say the pair will fall apart within a month.
Hamza Idrissi3 min read
Headphones under $50: wired, wireless or earbuds
Headphones under $50 can sound good if you pick the right type. Here is when wired beats wireless, what to check, and what cheap models skimp on.
Hamza Idrissi6 min read
How to pick a watch under $50 that lasts
What a watch under $50 can do well, which water-resistance ratings to trust, and how to tell a good cheap watch from a bad one before you buy.
Hamza Idrissi3 min read
Bath towels under $50: how to pick a set that lasts
Bath towels under $50 can last for years if you check weight, fiber and stitching. Here is what to look at, how many to buy and how to wash them.
Hamza Idrissi3 min read
Desk lamp under $50: what to look for
A desk lamp under $50 should be adjustable, bright enough and warm or neutral in color. Here is what to check, and one feature you can skip.
Manon Lambert2 min read